Conneaut Lake, PA Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Silver Shores Restaurant $$ 65 reviews American, Seafood, Italian (814) 382-4471 11934 Conneaut Lake RdConneaut Lake, PA 16316 Iroquois Boating & Fishing Club $ 9 reviews New American (814) 382-3075 10733 Konneyaut TrlConneaut Lake, PA 16316 Vacavi Cafe $ 36 reviews Cafes, Coffee & Tea, Breakfast & Brunch (814) 213-0119 100 Water StConneaut Lake, PA 16316 Toni's Lake Diner $ 12 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Soup, Burgers (814) 382-0244 130 Water StConneaut Lake, PA 16316 Ice House Bakery & Deli $ 9 reviews Bakeries, Delis (814) 213-0076 390 Water StConneaut Lake, PA 16316 Aces Bar and Gril image/svg+xml $ 2 reviews American (814) 382-1887 11058 State Highway 18Conneaut Lake, PA 16316